Judges for the Pony Medal were Karen Healey of Thousand Oaks, CA and John Roper of Franklin, TN.
Competitors qualify to compete in this event by winning a blue ribbon or by accumulating 30 points in a USEF Pony Medal Class at a USEF-sanctioned competition between July 2, 2003, and July 1, 2004.
Results are as follows:
| Place | Name | Hometown |
|---|---|---|
| Champion | Victoria Birdsall | Topsfield, MA |
| Reserve Champion | Lindsay Sceats | Colorado Springs, CO |
| Third | Reed Kessler | Bedford Corners, NY |
| Fourth | Calder Billhardt | Darien, CT |
| Fifth | Jennifer Waxman | Chagrin Falls, OH |
| Sixth | Jessica Springsteen | Colts Neck, NJ |
| Seventh | Sarah Sturges | Columbus, OH |
| Eighth | Hallie Buttenweiser | South Salem, NY |
| Ninth | Stephanie Vijan | Westerville, OH |
| Tenth | Taylor Harpman | Manakin Sabot, VA |

